I'm in the hardware store, and there's only one hammer left. I need it, and so does Person #1. We agree to split the price and share the hammer, flipping a coin to see who gets to use it first. I win, and on my way out of the store, Person #2 speeds by on a motorcycle and grabs the hammer out of my hand. He screeches around the corner, and I hear the sound of breaking glass as Person #1 starts screaming at me for losing the hammer. We run around the corner to see the hammer protruding from my now-broken windshield and Person #2 and his motorcycle on the ground, having lost control on a pile of ball bearings that Person #1 had accidentally dropped on his way into the hardware store. Now all three of us are hospitalized, Person #1 and myself having beat the living daylights out of each other.
a. What was the name of the hardware store?
b. Person #2 wants to sue you. What result?
c. You are a judge in the Southern District of New York. You are also related to Person #2. You also sit on the board of directors of the hammer manufacturer. Person #2 wants to know of any remedies that may be available from legal action against the hardware store. Advise.
Please concisely address and resolve all issues raised. Do not assume facts that are not given in the question. You may find it helpful to outline your answer on scratch paper before you begin typing. You may consult books and other printed materials, but you may not discuss the question with another person until after you have submitted your answer. Type your answer below, and press the button when finished.